"Australian Theologian takes Archaeologists and Historians to CourtWe will post BenDedek's four part series here on LexiLine as it appears, starting with Part 1 in the next posting. Our comment to BenDedek is "BRAVO!".
Download this press release as an Adobe PDF document
[at] http://pdfserver.prweb.com/pdfdownload/318005/pr.pdf
Australian theologian, historian and newspaper columnist, R.P.BenDedek has accused a number of archaeologists and historians, of using false documentary evidence to support claims in relation to the history of the Ancient Near East.
(PRWEB) December 4, 2005 -- Australian theologian, historian and newspaper columnist, R.P. BenDedek has accused a number of archaeologists and Historians, of using false documentary evidence to support claims in relation to the history of the Ancient Near East.
In a four part series of 'legal' articles entitled "The Law, Rules of Evidence & Archaeology", BenDedek, using both Australian and American Law, has written a judicial cross examination of witnesses, to prove that evidence used by academics to reconstruct the history of Assyria, Syria, Judah and Israel, would not be permitted in a court of law, and that their conclusions would not be 'beyond reasonable doubt'.
Claiming their evidence is legally 'false evidence', he suggests that prejudice and bias are the reasons why academics knowingly use factually erroneous evidence.
In one criticism, he writes: "if you logically follow some 'contrary academic explanations' that are offered without 'evidence', the fanciful theory ultimately turns into a 'conspiracy theory', that defies both evidence and logic."
Whilst admitting errors exist in Israel's historical records, and allowing Academics to draw inferences from fragmentary evidence, BenDedek is adamant that they cannot be allowed to 'pass off opinions as actual evidence of the facts'.
The Judge in BenDedek's criminal law cross examination exercise received the verdict from the jury, and promptly threw the academic evidence out of court.
Full story: The Law, Rules of Evidence & Archaeology Part 1.
http://www.kingscalendar.com/cgi-bin/index.cgi?action=viewnews&id=256"
Wednesday, December 07, 2005
Archaeologists and Historians taken to Court by R.P. BenDedek - LexiLine Journal 371
This is an interesting press release about someone who has clearly become fed up with the way in which archaeologists and historians juggle the evidence (or non-evidence) to suit their fancies. We have often said that most archaeological theories of the mainstream about the Middle East would be thrown out of court, and BenDedek has rightly come to the same conclusion.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Most Popular Posts of All Time
-
The Phaistos Disc: An Ancient Enigma Solved - by Andis Kaulins [1] Presented 31 October 2008 at the INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON THE PHAISTO...
-
The tomb of Senenmut (also written Senmut, both are wrong as we show in the next posting) located as Tomb TT353 at Del el-Bahri, Egypt, has...
-
Writing Origins! This is one my most important postings ever because it is an important step forward in resolving the question of the origin...
-
Who was Tutankhamun and was he murdered by the Philistines? Nearly five years ago I made a posting to the LexiLine group on the History ...
-
I received an email recently alerting me to the fascinating megalithic underwater site of Atlit-Yam in Israel. The Israel Antiquities ...
-
The terms Semite and Semitic were first coined by the German historian August Ludwig von Schlözer only in the modern era in the year 1781...
-
I am still working on my formal write-up of my Gobekli Tepe decipherment which will show that Göbekli Tepe is astronomical in nature and...
-
I received an inquiry relating to Agoza which indicated that I needed to post some more information about it. Agoza is merely the site of an...
-
Turin Canon of Kings to be Revised : More Fragments Discovered THIS IS SENSATIONAL NEWS! Ancient Tides is a nice blog by Gregory LeFever...
LexiLine Journal Archive
-
▼
2005
(66)
-
▼
December
(11)
- Various Holiday Greetings and Notices to End the Y...
- Quotations on Scholarship - LexiLine Journal 378
- Errors in Biblical Chronology II - LexiLine Journa...
- Errors in Roman Chronology - LexiLine Journal 376
- The Law, Rules of Evidence & Archaeology Part 4 by...
- The Law, Rules of Evidence & Archaeology Part 3 by...
- The Law, Rules of Evidence & Archaeology Part 2 by...
- The Law, Rules of Evidence & Archaeology Part 1 by...
- Archaeologists and Historians taken to Court by R....
- The Hopi Pawnee Connection - LexiLine Journal 370
- The Pawnee in Nebraska Had a Hermetic Astronomical...
-
▼
December
(11)
No comments:
Post a Comment